Why Choose Us?

Why should you choose Cole Insurance Agency?

We have over 135 years of combined experience in our office. Our staff is familiar with the unique situations that arise in rural Northern Michigan and are well equipped to handle them. We value the life long relationships we have with our customers. Additionally, we understand that insurance can be confusing and, at times, overwhelming and we pride ourselves on helping our insureds through the process. We always put the needs of our customers first.

At Cole Insurance Agency, our greatest strengths are experience and customer service. A large number of our insureds have been with us for 25 years or more. We value those long term customers and strive to make our new clients life long customers as well. We do this by treating them fairly. They are our friends and neighbors and we treat them that way.

What makes us different?

Our people make us different. We pride ourselves on going to the extra mile to help our customers. When you call our office, you speak to an agent, not a voicemail. Our employees have the knowledge and know-how to write policies that protect our customers best interest while understanding they aren’t made of money. We know that in a small town our reputation is our most valuable asset. We have grown that reputation over the course of 50 years as a company that cares.